Steering Your Calls: Improving Customer Experience in the Auto Insurance Industry

Phone calls are integral to the success of your insurance business. In addition to a strong website and solid social media presence, the key to driving a fantastic customer experience (and improving your insurance marketing efforts) is a good phone call.

The Keys to Customer Experience

Picture this: you’re an auto insurance provider making calls to current and future customers. Your policyholders have questions about their car’s policy – whether it’s an overdue bill, a request for a quote, or the urge to upgrade/downgrade their coverage. But you can’t get through, and now they’ve found a provider that gives a more responsive, more personal customer experience.

So why aren’t they answering the phone? Your outbound call numbers may have problems you don’t know about (aka, an unknown or flagged number). And we all know what unknown numbers will get you: nada, zilch, nothing.

Auto warranty scams have also risen to unprecedented levels, leaving customers afraid to answer an unknown call. Estimates now say that 1 billion scam calls are made to customers – per month!

Survey Says …

This year, we conducted a survey about insurance customer communication preferences and the troubles that come with unidentified numbers.

The survey revealed that a significant portion of people wants a phone call. Nearly half (49%) of policyholders prefer a live conversation when they need to talk to their insurance provider, and 2 in 5 say a phone call is an ideal way to connect.

If businesses want to continue providing value to customers, then strong ethics and good customer experience must be top of mind. The insurance industry specifically finds it challenging to get people to answer and engage in communication, but when your communication efforts are top-notch, it boosts the customer experience.

This is good for providers, right? Unfortunately, just knowing customer preferences isn’t enough. More than 3 in 4 people stated they missed calls because they didn’t know who was calling.

Policyholders are ready to answer your calls, and clearly identifying who’s calling is just one way to improve the insurance customer experience.

Picking the Perfect Auto Insurance Policy

Selecting the right insurance for your policy is a big deal. Choosing a beneficial policy plan takes a lot of thinking, talking, and decision-making.

Policy deadlines are time-sensitive, so it’s critical to connect with policyholders as soon as possible. Nearly 60% of people said missing a call from their provider created a “moderate to big impact.” And roughly 1 in 5 said that missing these calls cost them valuable time and/or affected them financially.

You can’t have that!

What’s one way to improve the policyholder experience and increase call volume and engagement – all while building trust between client and business? Properly identifying your outbound phone calls.

Branded Communications – The Proof is in the Results

In a recent case study, an auto insurance marketplace attempted to reach out to current clients after they filled out an online form inquiring about an insurance plan. Customers weren’t answering calls, and the auto insurance company was losing potential business as a result.

To solve their little problem, the marketplace invested in our Branded Communications solutions. Rather than leaving the number unknown, the company labeled itself for each outbound call, resulting in these improvements:

If you want your customers to answer, kick unknown numbers to the curb and label your calls with Branded Communications.

More sales mean more success. With Branded Communications, customers can be reached at just the right time. Another client of ours – a direct-to-consumer insurance company – experienced a considerable improvement when using our Branded Text Display solution, INFORM. Have we piqued your interest? Learn more.

Christine Hegg, Senior Partnership Manager at First Orion, named to CRN's 2026 Women of the Channel list.
May 4, 2026

Christine Hegg of First Orion Named to 2026 CRN Women of the Channel

First Orion's Christine Hegg, Senior Partnership Manager, has been named to CRN's 2026 Women of the Channel list, recognizing her leadership in expanding First Orion's channel ecosystem and driving partner-led growth.
Read More
First Orion Introduces SIP Redirect Call Authentication Integration to Expand Access to Trusted, Logo Branded Calling
April 30, 2026

First Orion Introduces SIP Redirect Call Authentication Integration

First Orion has introduced a new patented SIP redirect-based call authentication integration that lets enterprises authenticate outbound calls and deliver INFORM Branded Calling at scale, while expanding access to call authentication beyond the limits of in-band frameworks like STIR/SHAKEN.
Read More
First Orion Signs Agreement to Deliver INFORM Branded Calling to Boost Mobile Subscribers
April 8, 2026

First Orion Signs Agreement to Deliver INFORM® Branded Calling to Boost Mobile Subscribers

First Orion has signed an agreement with Boost Mobile to deliver INFORM® Branded Calling, enabling Boost subscribers to see business display names on incoming calls and expanding branded calling reach for First Orion customers.
Read More

the solution behind every trusted connection

From small businesses to global enterprises, First Orion helps you increase answer rates, verify identity, and build customer trust and transparency.

AFFIRM®

Reputation Monitoring

Benefits

  • Ensure Your Outbound Call Display Is Correct
  • Increase Your contact Rates
  • Increase agent productivity
  • Strengthen brand reputation

Monitor how your outbound calls appear and catch labeling errors fast.  

SENTRY®

Call
Blocking

Block bad actors from spoofing your numbers, protecting trust with your customers.

Benefits

  • Protect your brand reputation
  • Protect your customers from fraud
  • Prevents the need to waste time and money on fraud incident resolution
  • Increase customer retention and loyalty

PROTECT+

Risk Detection

Detect suspicious inbound call activity in real time with intelligent risk analysis.

Benefits

  • Detect incoming spam and scam
  • Protect your business from risky calls
  • Increase connection with good callers
  • Improve call agent experience