Improve the Customer Experience During Open Enrollment Period (And Beyond)

It’s everyone’s favorite time of year – open enrollment season! (Sorry, it’s not quite the holiday season yet.) Insurance companies and third-party administrators are gearing up for a hectic enrollment period. While companies are returning to benefits fairs and in-person meetings to discuss their 2023 benefit plans, employees are often left with additional questions after they leave. After all, we’re talking about choices that can have a sizable impact on a person’s finances and healthcare. How can a customer service organization build trust in its products and services while providing a satisfactory customer experience at the same time? A phone call could be the key component to a smooth open enrollment experience.

What is Open Enrollment?

Open enrollment is the time of year when people evaluate their benefits for the following year. Whether a person is getting healthcare insurance and other benefits through their employer or shopping via a healthcare exchange, there are a lot of details to take in.

More often than not, people take the information home not knowing exactly what they’re going to choose. They need to review their finances, talk with their significant others, review changes to their healthcare plan, etc.

Perhaps they’re starting a family in the new year, enrolling their kids in daycare, or planning on retirement. These typically aren’t decisions people make on the spur of the moment; they need to ask additional questions so they can plan properly.

People may also be filling out policy applications (or other forms) and need clarification. As a result, they’re going to reach out to a customer service agent or their third-party administrators.

Communication and the Open Enrollment Experience

The open enrollment experience varies from company to company. Many businesses use benefits fairs or open enrollment meetings; it gives employees the chance to ask questions face-to-face and have their questions answered. In the past few years, there has also been a shift in the workplace with more people working from home or from another remote location. In these situations, agencies or companies may pre-record their messages or post FAQ pages; while convenient, these formats don’t allow for a question-and-answer period.

Regardless of whether a person attends a live benefits meetings or has remote enrollment – many people need to talk to an agent or administrator about their specific situation.

While Baby Boomers and Generation Xers like face-to-face communications and phone calls, Millennials and Gen Zers prefer digital forms of communication such as email, video, or text messages.

However, when people have long and complicated questions, First Orion found that 49% of insurance customers prefer talking with a live person over the phone rather than through email, messaging apps and text messages. A phone call allows people to ask both initial and follow-up questions. It also provides a quicker, more immediate response than an email or scouring the web for an FAQ.

End of the Year Questions

What happens outside of open enrollment? Since most plans run on the calendar year (Jan. 1 – Dec. 31), a lot of people have a slew of other questions they need answers to. In turn, customer service teams could be making additional follow-up calls to answer questions such as:

These types of questions help people plan better. They can schedule a procedure ahead of time and understand their financial commitments. A staple of customer service is a quick follow-up so that people can get the answers they need.

Deliver Calls Made to Answer

Calling people back can be tedious, especially if they are not answering and engaging. Since so many people are wary of scam callers, 87% won’t answer a call from an unknown number.

But even callback requests have their shortcomings if you fail to brand your calls. According to our report, nearly 3 in 5 people missed a call from a call back request because they didn’t recognize the incoming call number. That ultimately leads to more time making repeated calls, and trying to get in touch with the right person at the right time.

Moreover, keeping your clients (both people and businesses) satisfied can maintain a steady stream of revenue and increase client loyalty.

There is a way to deliver a better customer experience, increase application processing, and new net income; plus, you can streamline your application processing during the open enrollment season. With a Branded Communications solution, you can deliver your name and reason for calling. When a company identifies itself on a person’s incoming call screen, the individual is more likely to answer and talk. In fact, a branded call can lead to an 18% lift in application conversion rates.

Improve the open enrollment experience for your clients and account holders, establish trust in your company, increase revenue, and retain your clients with a branded call.

August 4, 2026

First Orion Wins 2026 Pinnacle Award for Cybersecurity

First Orion has been named a Platinum Winner in the 2026 Pinnacle Technology Awards, earning Cybersecurity & Data Privacy recognition for Identity Verification & Fraud Prevention. The award recognizes First Orion’s SENTRY Call Blocking and INFORM Branded Calling solutions, which help carriers block suspected fraudulent calls and enable verified businesses to display their identity on consumers’ mobile screens.
Read More
First Orion Head of Product Josh Whitehurst, named one of Arkansas Money & Politics' 2026 Future Icons.
July 28, 2026

First Orion’s Josh Whitehurst Named a 2026 Future Icon

First Orion Head of Product Josh Whitehurst has been named one of Arkansas Money & Politics’ 2026 Future Icons, an annual recognition honoring 100 rising leaders from across the state who are making a meaningful impact through business, entrepreneurship, public service, and community leadership.
Read More
First Orion launched Mobile Originated Branded Calling (MOBC) with T-Mobile, enabling authenticated branded calls directly from mobile devices.
July 21, 2026

First Orion Launches Mobile Branded Calling with T-Mobile

First Orion has launched Mobile Originated Branded Calling (MOBC) with T-Mobile, an industry-first wireless provider deployment that lets business customers initiate authenticated branded calls directly from mobile devices—displaying verified brand name, logo, call reason, and a preferred callback number on supported devices.
Read More

the solution behind every trusted connection

From small businesses to global enterprises, First Orion helps you increase answer rates, verify identity, and build customer trust and transparency.

Dashboard showing a circular progress chart, a vertical bar graph, and a list with blue and white items.

AFFIRM®

Reputation Monitoring

Monitor how your outbound calls appear and catch labeling errors fast.  

Smartphone screen showing incoming call from +1 (212) 555-8724 with a green call approved badge.

SENTRY®

Call
Blocking

Block bad actors from spoofing your numbers, protecting trust with your customers.

Labels showing risk levels with phone numbers: Low Risk green check, High Risk red alert, Medium Risk orange alert.

PROTECT+

Risk Detection

Detect suspicious inbound call activity in real time with intelligent risk analysis.